Our decide
A longtime favourite amongst our testers, this pillow has moldable, customizable filling that provides agency help for back- and side-sleepers. What it doesn’t have: the lingering chemical scent we’ve observed in another shredded-foam pillows.
This customizable down-alternative pillow is softer than shredded foam, so it’s higher for stomach-sleepers who want much less loft than the Nest Bedding Straightforward Breather supplies. It’s additionally a lot much less messy to regulate.
The Nest Bedding Straightforward Breather Pillow has been a constant tester favourite for its agency, adjustable help. It’s probably the most comfy shredded-foam pillows we’ve discovered, and there isn’t a persistent drawback with smelly foam (which we’ve encountered with shredded-foam pillows from different corporations).
The Straightforward Breather has a tender, cool cowl, and the shredded foam is encased in its personal washable internal pouch (making it the primary absolutely washable shredded-foam pillow we’ve examined). The pouch additionally has a zipper, so you’ll be able to add or take away shredded-foam filling to attain your preferrred loft. This could be a messy course of, but it surely does allow you to obtain a exact match.
The Straightforward Breather is available in 4 sizes, together with a side-sleeper model with a curved edge to your shoulder (which we haven’t but examined). This pillow comes with a 30-day return coverage and a two-year guarantee.
The Sleep Quantity PlushComfort Pillow Final is the one customizable down-alternative pillow we’ve ever examined, and it’s preferrred for stomach-sleepers who’ve a tough time discovering the fitting peak. (“Down various” is a fluffy fill, normally polyester or rayon, that mimics the texture of down however prices a lot much less.)
Most pillows we’ve tried are available tender, medium, or agency densities. However the PlushComfort Pillow Final contains all three choices in a single pillow: It comes with three sealed, detachable layers of fill that will help you obtain one of the best match to your physique form.
Most of our testers (even some back- and side-sleepers, who usually favor shredded foam) discovered a snug peak and loved the cushioned help of the PlushComfort Pillow Final. Sleep Quantity has just lately modified its no-return coverage to a 100-day return coverage by mail, and the corporate additionally supplies a one-year restricted guarantee on its pillows.
Improve decide
This shredded-foam, down-alternative pillow has detachable layers, so it’s simpler to tailor to completely different physique shapes than others we’ve examined. And it affords loads of neck help for back- and side-sleepers.
This supportive but moldable down pillow has a agency density. And the corporate affords a lifetime assure—essentially the most complete of any coverage we discovered.
The Sleep Quantity ComfortFit Pillow Final is among the loftiest shredded-foam pillows we’ve examined. And there are three sealed, detachable layers inside, so this pillow is simpler to customise than any others we tried. It’s just like the Sleep Quantity PlushComfort Pillow Final, however this one makes use of a mixture of shredded foam and down various, as an alternative of simply down various. (Don’t confuse this pillow with one other shredded-foam pillow we tried, the Sleep Quantity ComfortFit Pillow Traditional, which isn’t adjustable.)
We imagine the PlushComfort Pillow Final is the most suitable choice for side- and back-sleepers who aren’t certain how a lot loft they actually need. That’s as a result of adjusting this pillow is tidier than adjusting our Straightforward Breather decide (which has free clumps of froth that may be messy to mould).
Like our different Sleep Quantity decide, the PlushComfort Pillow Final, this pillow comes with a 100-day return coverage by mail and features a one-year guarantee in opposition to defects.
In our years of testing, we’ve discovered that down has a really particular enchantment. If you’re keen on it, observe that our stomach-sleepers particularly most well-liked the firm-density Garnet Hill Signature White Down Pillow, with its give and softness, to different down pillows we’ve tried over the previous 4 years (with 11 sleep testers).
This pillow is simpler to form to your shoulders and neck than different down pillows we’ve tried. In our newest testing, a number of back- and side-sleepers (who in testing have sometimes most well-liked taller pillows) additionally favored the agency Garnet Hill. It’s the one down-pillow decide on this information, and it’s Accountable Down Licensed (RDS).
Garnet Hill has a 90-day return coverage and a one-year guarantee in opposition to defects.
Price range decide
This adjustable pillow is extra inexpensive than different shredded-foam pillows we’ve tried, and it affords agency help for back-, side-, and a few stomach-sleepers. Nonetheless, in some earlier testing we’ve observed a robust chemical scent.
We’ve been recommending the Xtreme Comforts Shredded Reminiscence Foam Pillow since 2016, and it was a high decide in earlier variations of this information. Over time, a number of staffers and readers have reported that this pillow has often arrived with a notably sturdy chemical scent. And after we examined 4 Xtreme Comforts pillows, half of them smelled so dangerous that we couldn’t get to sleep; even after a number of weeks, the scent didn’t fade (the opposite half of the pillows have been odorless).
Nonetheless, previously few years, we haven’t seen complaints from readers or staffers a few chemical scent, so we expect the issue might have been resolved—we’ll retest in a future replace to make certain.
The Xtreme Comforts pillow has a medium loft, and you may mould or alter the filling to make it comfy for individuals with varied physique varieties and sleep positions (even a few of our stomach-sleepers have actually favored this pillow). It sometimes prices half the worth of the Nest Bedding Straightforward Breather, and the corporate affords a 30-day no-questions-asked return coverage.
