- A San Francisco-based Lyft driver stated Waymo’s self-driving taxis have made the job extra aggressive.
- He additionally stated the rising variety of ride-hailing drivers has made it tougher to earn money.
- The growth of self-driving providers in San Francisco has come underneath heightened scrutiny.
Nick Boenzi, a part-time Lyft driver in his 40s, stated the aggressive nature of ride-hailing has made it troublesome for him to earn money. And it’s not simply his fellow drivers in San Francisco who he has to take care of.
That’s as a result of a whole bunch of self-driving taxis from the Alphabet-owned Waymo are additionally selecting up riders in San Francisco — Boenzi sees the distinctive white autos a number of occasions an hour whereas driving. He stated these taxis aren’t solely competing with him for riders — however infringing upon his handiest ride-hailing technique.
“Self-driving automobiles in San Francisco are taking essentially the most worthwhile rides which have the best pay-per-mile,” he advised Enterprise Insider through e mail. “The quick rides.”
If a driver needs to take advantage of cash as quick as potential, Boenzi stated lengthy rides are the best way to go. But when they need to be worthwhile, he stated shorter rides are higher as a result of they have a tendency to pay extra per mile, making them extra profitable as soon as driving bills like gasoline, depreciation, and upkeep prices are thought-about.
Boenzi stated a journey is just value it if it pays at the very least $1 a mile, together with any miles spent relocating to a busier space after a journey ends. He’d somewhat make $14 in an hour driving 4 miles than $25 in the identical hour driving 32 miles.
The issue, in accordance with Boenzi, is that riders have a tendency to show to Waymo taxis for shorter rides — partially as a result of these autos aren’t allowed on the freeways simply but. When he can’t discover quick rides to his liking, he usually heads to San Francisco Worldwide Airport, the place Boenzi stated he usually finds the most worthwhile “longer rides.”
However he stated the airport has additionally turn out to be more and more aggressive as extra drivers flip to it for purchasers.
“The airports normally can assure enterprise — when it will get sluggish, that’s the place individuals will go,” he stated. “However there have been over 200 drivers ready all day day by day it appears. And it’s getting tougher day by day.”
Extra drivers, journey challenges, and self-driving taxis make ride-hailing aggressive
Getty Pictures
When Lyft has “journey challenges,” which incentivize drivers to finish a sure variety of journeys by a deadline to earn a bonus, Boenzi stated the competitors can get much more intense.
The week of October 16 to 22 — when Boenzi stated there was a journey problem in impact — he earned $217 earlier than Lyft took its minimize in 15 hours of booked time, in accordance with a doc seen by BI. Roughly a month earlier than, when he stated there wasn’t a problem, he earned practically $1,400 in 43 hours of booked time. Regardless of solely having roughly thrice as many booked hours, his earnings have been over six occasions increased than the problem week.
Boenzi is one in every of a number of ride-hailing drivers who’ve advised BI that an improve in drivers has contributed to fewer out there — and lower-paying — journeys. In November 2023, Uber introduced it had a report 6.5 million lively drivers and couriers. This got here after the variety of international Uber drivers elevated by over 30% in 2022 to a report 5 million. Within the fall of 2022, Lyft stated it had its highest quantity of lively drivers in over two years. Lyft did not reply to BI’s query concerning the progress of drivers lately.
Many drivers say the rollout of Uber and Lyft’s “up-front fares” options — which have supplied drivers with extra info about journeys earlier than they settle for them — have additionally resulted in decrease pay. Some drivers say this has impacted their earnings greater than the aggressive driving panorama.
Boenzi stated he isn’t positive how rather more aggressive Waymo’s taxis have made ride-hailing, however he thinks it may very well be a giant purpose some drivers are seeing much less demand within the metropolis and crowding at airports. Waymo did not reply to BI’s query about competitors.
A Lyft spokesperson advised BI through e mail that the everyday US driver is incomes over $30 per utilized hour, together with ideas and bonuses, and that the corporate has a wholesome enterprise in San Francisco. In an e mail, Uber advised BI that its drivers stay busy, their earnings are sturdy, and extra ride-hailing prospects are on the platform than ever earlier than.
In 2023, Boenzi earned practically $22,000 after Lyft charges throughout roughly 1,700 journeys and 25,000 on-line miles, in accordance with a doc seen by BI.
Lyft has a self-driving partnership with the riderless expertise firm Motional in Las Vegas, which has led to the completion of over 100,000 self-driving Lyft journeys.
Uber has two self-driving partnerships — one with Waymo in Phoenix and the opposite with Motional in Las Vegas. The corporate stated it has not seen any important impacts on drivers’ earnings in these cities.
Driverless automobiles have come underneath scrutiny in San Francisco
Earlier than final August, Waymo and Cruise, majority-owned by Normal Motors, collectively had over 500 self-driving taxis working in San Francisco. However they have been solely allowed to supply journeys in sure components of town throughout sure components of the day.
However an August ruling by the California Public Utilities Fee opened the door for these corporations to offer 24-hour service to all the metropolis, excluding freeways. Nonetheless, the rollout was bumpy.
One week following the ruling, Cruise agreed to minimize its driverless fleet in half following two reviews of crashes. In October, San Francisco banned Cruise from working in San Francisco after it did not disclose video footage of a girl being pinned underneath one in every of its autos.
Waymo’s rollout additionally hasn’t been good. On Saturday, a San Francisco crowd set a Waymo taxi on fireplace. Nobody was injured, and the motive for the incident is unclear.
However in contrast to Cruise, Waymo continues to function within the metropolis. The corporate advised BI it has a pair hundred self-driving taxis in its San Francisco fleet.
Driving full-time can result in burnout
Boenzi stated he began driving for Lyft in 2023 as a result of he wasn’t making as a lot as he used to by renting out his autos by means of the Turo platform — and he wanted additional earnings to assist repay his substantial quantity of bank card debt.
He stated he tries to drive a number of days in a row if he can however that he typically has to take a number of days off as a result of driving might be draining, notably when he has to sit down in plenty of visitors.
Along with in search of shorter journeys, Boenzi stated he’s had success pivoting to meals supply platforms when ride-hailing is sluggish — he stated these typically pay extra per mile than ride-hailing.
Going ahead, Boenzi stated he’d like to begin one other passive earnings enterprise, reminiscent of a automotive wash, laundry mat, or merchandising machines enterprise. He used to work as a monetary analyst and stated returning to the same function may very well be an alternative choice.
As soon as he will get one other earnings stream, he stated he’ll seemingly cut back his Lyft hours.
“My driving days will quickly be only a couple hours a day, or I’ll take a break from driving till it’s extra worthwhile,” he stated.
Are you a gig employee keen to share your story about pay, schedule, and tipping? If that’s the case, attain out to those reporters at jzinkula@insider.com.
